This past Tuesday, LV summarized the Best of Both Worlds podcast topic for the week as: hiring hella childcare. And I’m struck again by how I don’t quite know where I belong socioeconomically. I read people who seem like me, but have a quarter million dollars saved for college – for each child. I read people who seem like me, but can pay two mortgages while they renovate a new house. I read people who seem like me, but have giant houses with beautiful interiors. I read people who seem like me, but go on incredible vacations to far flung places. I read people who seem like me, but send their kids to expensive private elementary and high schools. I read people who seem like me, but can hire full time child care.
And the reality is, people who have full time child care, especially while their youngest kid is in school, are not my people. I can barely make my own finances work; the thought of providing someone with their livelihood is insane to me. We have always paid for aftercare, which works because I am a teacher and get off early enough to pick up the kids by 6pm. But we had to do all kinds of crazy shit to make mornings work over the years. When my son was a baby, my FIL watched him from 9:00am to 1pm. I taught from 7am to 12:10pm straight (no breaks) and pumped in the car on the way to pick him up. We couldn’t even afford full time care when we actually needed it.
And yes, I know how lucky we were to have someone willing to watch our baby for us (those years are SO EXPENSIVE), but no one was providing full time child care on a schedule that worked for us. I was waking up all night with a newborn, then leaving the house at 6am to teach five classes in five hours, and then pick up my baby at lunch. We were making it work with FOUR HOURS of care a day. My husband got in late to work and left late, which means I was with the baby alone (after teaching full time) from 1pm to 7pm. And I had to get my daughter around 5pm. It was nuts. Once they started school I had to ask for 1st period prep for years, so I could drop them off at 7:50am and book it down to my job. If I hit traffic I had to call a friend to cover for me. It was horrible. And I spent my prep commuting so I had not time at work to get anything done, which meant I stayed up late every night to do prep work at home. It was awful. No wonder I had no ambition during those years. I was just trying to survive.
And yet. We live in one of the most expensive cities in the country. And we own a house in that city (or a mortgage lender owns one in our name). I suppose that is where the comparisons just seem to fall apart. Our mortgage is 2-3x that of mortgages for a similarly sized house in most other parts of the country. (And our house would probably sell for two times that now). We choose to live here for a number of reasons, and high on that list is grandparents, who do provide support (and provided more when our kids were babies). I sometimes wonder though, if being as house poor as we were is actually worth the grandparent help (it probably is, but only because of how much our house has increased in value). Paying for a full time nanny here probably costs 1.5x or 2x what it costs in other parts of the country. So maybe I don’t really know what I’m talking about.
So yeah. I just don’t feel like I understand where I fit, who my people are. I do fit pretty well with my real-life friends, the ones I know now, which is part of why I think we get along so well. But they all live here and again, I wonder if living in the Bay Area skews things so much that you can’t really compare yourself with people elsewhere. All the metrics are off. I think many of the blogs I read have similar-ish incomes (many have much higher incomes I’m sure, but some I think are comparable), but their mortgages are so much less than mine. If your monthly mortgage payment is cut in half, that’s a big difference in disposable income.
And sure, we get to go to Hawaii this summer, for the second time, but only because a friend invited us. And they get to go because a friend invited them. We could never afford the trip on our own. We went to London last summer, to visit my sister, but only because my parents paid for the AirBnB, and a massive tax return allowed us to cover the air fare. Our other two big trips were to very cheap countries, and we rented our house out on AirBnB to help cover the expenses.
{I forgot to mention we had to rent out a portion of our house for 8 years, just to cover our mortgage – that is why we got the massive tax return, because we took a loss being landlords for so long.}
Yes, we own a house that is worth a lot, but we struggle with basic upkeep, let alone renovating parts of it that we don’t like. We’ve wanted to replace our garage door for 5 years (you have to get out and swing it open manually), but whenever we save up enough to do it, a plumbing or electrical emergency requires we divert those funds. We can’t use an entire room because of water damage from this year’s storms (the walls are COVERED in mold).
We have very little saved for our kids’ college education. We’re considering halting our contributions to our son’s 529 to pay for a house cleaner. (We only just started contributing to his 529 a couple years ago, when we started contributing to his sister’s 529. She is 3.5 years older.)
And yet, I’m assured, we are solidly upper middle class. Are the people who seem to have more, wealthy? Or is upper middle class just such a big, nebulous category that we both exist within it? Or is it again, where we live? Is upper middle class in the Bay Area just look different?
It doesn’t really matter. I’m just trying to understand why my experience seems so different sometimes. I guess I shouldn’t expect to find a lot of similarities with people in the private sector, finance, law or medicine. We are a public middle school teacher and a city employee. Of course it’s not the same.
It’s funny because generationally I feel adrift as well. I was born in 1980, so some articles declare I’m Gen X and others a Millennial. I always identified more with Gen X, but now that Millennials are getting older, much of what I read about their experience also rings true. Again, it doesn’t really matter, but I do find it frustrating that I don’t seem to fit anywhere, that it’s so hard to feel like I belong.
Even with my friends, because I had kids early (relatively, in the Bay Area having a kid at 30 is very, very early) it’s hard to find my tribe. (I think this part of me identifies as Gen X). Most moms with kids my daughter’s age are a full decade older than me. (Sometimes I’m grateful for my DOR because I’m going through perimenopause with them, even though they are 10-12 years older). I can find moms about 5 years older than me with kids in my son’s grade, but that kid is their oldest (and there aren’t many of them). My friends from college have kids 8-10 years younger than mine, if they have them at all (many don’t). And of course in my profession I feel alone, seeing as I’m the only foreign language teacher in my entire district. Even at the dojo I’m one of the only adults over 35, and one of only a small handful that has kids.
So yeah, I’ve just been noticing it lately, as my blog roll whittles to a group of people that I thought I could identify with, but that are actually living very different lives, and managing very different concerns. Maybe most people feel like this, like everyone has it different enough that it’s not really comparable. Or maybe I’m just focusing on the wrong things, because I’m burnt out and other people’s problems seem easier to manage than my own. (Surely the real issue is that I just don’t want to manage my problems, and I’m feeling salty about them.)
I actually started a post about realizing I’m burnt out today, but then I came back to finish this one first. I hope I don’t come off like an ass. It’s really not about people having more than me, because I have so much and honestly don’t need more. I probably couldn’t even manage more, or it wouldn’t make a difference. That’s probably it, because I have more now than I did 5 years ago, but I’m still coming up against the same kinds of problems, so maybe this is just how I operate. (But also, everything costs so much more than it did 5 years ago, I don’t know how much “more” I really, in effect, have. Certainly not as much more as the numbers on paper would suggest.) It’s just about feeling like I don’t really fit in, like I can’t find my people. It would be so nice to meet someone, or read someone and think, oh yes! This person is just like me!
But maybe no one ever feels that way. Maybe I’m just looking for something that no one ever truly has.
How about you? Do you feel like you look around and see people like you? Or do you always feel just different enough for it to be noticeable? Does anyone feel like they belong anywhere?