Thanks you for the conversation last Thursday. One thing I thinks is clear, is that different people are having different experiences in different parts of the country. I live in city that has been held up as paragon of low death rates during the pandemic. More people have died of overdose during the pandemic in San Francisco than Covid. The Bay Area was one of the first to shut down in March of 2020, and we’ve continued to “take this seriously” ever since. San Francisco Unified School District was also one of the last to return to in-person learning, and when we did, our students got far less time in classrooms than their peers even in other parts of the Bay Area. People here are still very cautious – most people wear masks while walking around outside, and even in large open spaces like parks or the beach. My call for us to start talking about “off ramps” is very much in response to my lived experience here in the Bay Area. I would probably not be so worried about managing an eventual “return to normalcy” if I lived in an area where things already were starting to feel normal. Where I live, they are not.
Which brings me to some of the backlash surrounding this conversation, which generally seems to be around timing. I do want to reiterate that my post was not a call to end any and all restrictions RIGHT NOW. I know that, at least where I live, it’s going to take a LONG time for us to come out of this mentally and emotionally. If we start talking about it now, maybe when mask mandates are relaxed, those people who stop wearing them won’t get dirty looks from those who are continuing to wear them, and may continue to wear them indefinitely. We have a long way to go where I live, and we need to start having the conversation at some point. Starting these conversations now seems reasonable to me, even if it will be a few months, at least, before we could actually start relaxing restrictions. If we start talking about this stuff now, maybe we could put metrics in place for changing behaviors.
So, shall we engage in some light whataboutism? Why not.
Why not wait until the 5 and unders can be vaccinated?
It looks like vaccines might be available for our youngest cohort soon, maybe even in the next month. Of course their pending arrival is not being met with elation of past approvals, and currently only 25-30% of parents intend to vaccinate their children under 5 years old. But I understand that for those families who fear the worst outcomes, vaccinating their under 5 year olds is necessary for a return to normalcy. I’m so glad that those parents will have that chance soon. I know a huge weight was lifted off my shoulders when my kids were vaccinated, and even though I was never that fearful of them catching Covid. So I do think this milestone is necessary for us to move on, but only so the families who want to vaccinate their younger kids can feel safe. If the rate of vaccination for 5-11 year olds is only 25% at this point, I don’t think can expect vaccinations for younger kids to help us reach the level of “immunity” required to hasten community spread significantly.
But what about the crazy high rates of hospitalizations and deaths!
Obviously omicron is still raging in the United States. Sure we’re on the downward slope of the wave, but the wave was massive and our daily case rates are still much higher than what they were during the worst of the Delta wave. And hospitalizations rates and deaths are also very high in most of the country. The thing is, the vast majority of those hospitalizations and deaths are among the unvaccinated. These are people who have had almost a year to get vaccinated and are still not, for whatever reason. If we are changing our behaviors to keep people from being hospitalized and dying, and the vast majority of people being hospitalized and dying are unvaccinated, then we are asking everyone to change the way they live so that the people who aren’t vaccinated don’t get severely ill and die. And we’re asking them to do that, knowing that the unvaccinated are the last likely to be changing their behavior themselves – they are the least likely to mask, and rapid test before seeing others, or quarantine when they feel ill.
At this point it’s clear that the US will continue to have a much higher rate of severe illness and death than other large, wealthy nations because we have so many people who are not vaccinated. We say that “this is a pandemic of the unvaccinated” but at some point do we say that “this is a crisis because of the unvaccinated”? Or is that not fair? Or does it not matter either way?
I realized driving to work this morning that I wrote my last post not because I think public policy should change right now, or even in the next few months. I wrote this post because *I* personally need to start changing my own thought process around this. In my personal situation, where I live in a highly vaccinated area of mostly like-minded individuals, I need to start changing lanes. I need to start accurately assessing my own risk and the risk of my family because *we* are not doing great and I don’t think *we* are always following the science when we decide what we are and are not going to do. Thankfully I am not a public health official and I do not have to make decisions that affect others. All I can do is make decisions within the rules and guidelines provided by actual public health officials.
I want to be ready for the off ramp when it does come. I want to be ready for my kids to return to school unmasked when officials decide that is safe. I want to feel comfortable in my own classroom when that happens, and I need to start thinking about it now if I’m going to feel okay about it in the fall (which is the earliest it would ever happen around here, I’m sure). I think a lot of people where I live need to start thinking about these things now, so that when we do start inching towards normalcy, they will be mentally and emotionally prepared for it. Because right now we are not. And there are a lot of complicated, non-science-based reasons for that.
Thank you for reading along as I figure all this stuff out. It’s messy and it’s complicated and it’s important to talk about. I appreciate your input – it’s helpful to understand where other people are at and why.






