I found this article really interesting. It affirms the way I feel about parenting, describing more concisely the concerns I have with raising children these days than I ever could (with data to back it up).
I consider myself a free range parent. Well, maybe a wanna-be. I don’t think I can be the free-range parent that I want to be because my husband’s opinion is obviously important, but also because I have been spooked by the stories of people calling CPS on the parents of children who walk to the park alone. I know it’s a tired trope to look fondly on the freedom of one’s youth and mark all the ways children have lost that freedom today, but truly, I was allowed to do things alone in Hong Kong when I was in 4th, 5th and 6th grade that would make parents today blanch. I would like to give my children that kind of freedom, but I doubt I will be allowed, either by my immediate community, or society at large.
I’ve already started talking to my husband about how I expect our daughter will be able to get to school by herself in 6th grade, even if that means walking several blocks to a bus or MUNI train stop. Or even taking BART. I could manage that kind of daily responsibility on public transportation at that age (actually younger), why can’t she? (And yes, I understand she has to be taught how to ride public transportation – she does it frequently with us and we are always ensuring she takes the necessary steps herself, with our guidance.) What is the point of living in a city if you don’t let your kids get around by themselves? My husband has a moral aversion to the suburbs for a number of reasons, but one of the most significant is their lack of public transportation. And yet he doesn’t trust his kids, or the system (probably a bit of both) to take advantage of it.
The economic insecurity aspect of the piece also really hit home. There are parts of me that are still reeling at the reality that I will never be as well off as my parents. I grew up with stories of how they came from very little to become comfortably upper-middle class, despite a few poor professional and financial choices on my father’s part. If they could manage that kind of upward mobility, I figured my own future would be just as bright, if not brighter. And yet I will never have the financial stability they enjoyed. The systems they took for granted don’t exist anymore. Neither do the opportunities.
I do worry about our kids’ futures. Mostly I worry I’m not doing enough to prepare them for the disappointment they will certainly face. I assume they will have less than we do. One of the main reasons I’ve given up the dream of converting our downstairs unit into a master bedroom is I recognize my kids will probably need to live in that space rent-free, or at least at a very reduced cost. By the time I can be sure they no longer need that space we won’t want the extra square footage anyway.
I also worry they aren’t smart enough to guarantee their success, even though they are both very bright. I used to read a blog where the gifted status of the children was frequently touted. It caused me an extreme amount of anxiety and I couldn’t pin-point exactly why, until I connected the idea that gifted = successful, or at least financially secure. Of course I know that isn’t necessarily the case, that all sorts of factors contribute to a person’s success, but it’s easy to fall into the black and white ideas that pervade our cultural narrative.
I worry I don’t give them enough opportunities. Actually, I worry they aren’t hungry enough for those opportunities. My daughter would be content to participate in no extra curricular activities at all, especially if her friends weren’t doing anything. The only real reason she wants to do something is be with her friends, which isn’t a bad reason, but it worries me that it’s her only reason. I have to remind myself that she is only 8-years-old and has a life time to figure out what she is interested in and if she wants to pursue those interests. Heck, I even worry about my 5-year-old son, especially when I overhear conversations on the sidelines of soccer about how other kids already love the sport and can’t stop practicing it. (We stopped going to soccer over a year ago because my kid didn’t want to keep going and I still worry about it sometimes!)
I am a big proponent of not playing a lot with my kids. My husband and I disagree about this quite a bit. I think they should play by themselves, or with each other. And if they are bored, they should figure it out. My husband thinks we should be more involved and hands on when we are home. I recognize that he is with them a lot less, and it is important for them to have quality time with their dad, but I don’t think every minute of a weekend day should be spent engaging my kids on their level. I plan some activities and have their friends over, but I should also get to do my own shit. And I refuse to give up the time my kids spend in front of the TV. That is what TV is for, to get shit done. Yes I will watch good movies with my kids and talk to them about the moral or lesson of the story, but I’m not going to watch Teen Titans Go! season 3 with them for the umpteenth time (and I actually really like Teen Titans Go!)
I was just talking with my father-in-law about how intense parenting was. He brought up something about how much more intense it would be if I were a stay-at-home mother like his mom was. I was struggling to articulate all the ways it was different back then (or maybe he was struggling to here me). I sent him this paragraph before I even sent him the link to the article.
Over just a couple of generations, parents have greatly increased the amount of time, attention and money they put into raising children. Mothers who juggle jobs outside the home spend just as much time tending their children as stay-at-home mothers did in the 1970s.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/25/upshot/the-relentlessness-of-modern-parenting.htm
Maybe if he hears someone else saying it, he will actually believe it’s true. Parenting really is a different ball game than it was when our parents were raising kids, and a totally different sport than when their parents were raising them.